One of the most common questions new drivers ask is whether to go petrol, diesel, hybrid, or electric. The honest answer depends almost entirely on how and where you drive — but for most first-time buyers in the UK in 2025, the answer is probably simpler than you think.
Petrol is the right choice for the majority of first-time buyers. It's the most common engine type in the used car market, which means the widest choice of cars, the cheapest parts, and garages that can service them anywhere in the UK.
Best for: Most new drivers doing under 12,000 miles per year, town driving, commuting, mixed use.
Diesel made sense when motorway miles were high and fuel was cheap. In 2025, for most first-time buyers, it's a trap. The higher purchase price, more complex servicing, and the diesel particulate filter (DPF) issue make it a poor choice unless you genuinely do high mileage.
Best for: Drivers doing 15,000+ miles per year, mostly on A-roads and motorways. Not city drivers.
Hybrids have become genuinely compelling for first-time buyers, especially in city and suburban driving. The Toyota Yaris, Honda Jazz, and Renault Clio E-Tech hybrid all offer strong real-world economy without range anxiety.
Best for: City and suburban drivers, stop-start commuting, anyone who drives mostly under 40mph.
Electric is the future — but probably not for your first car in 2025. Used EV prices are volatile, battery health is hard to assess, and without a home charger the running cost advantage disappears. Unless you have a driveway charger and a budget of £8,000+, petrol or hybrid is the safer first car choice.
Best for: Buyers with a home charger, budget of £8,000+, and mostly local driving. Revisit in 2–3 years when the used market matures.
| Fuel type | Typical first car cost | Pence per mile | Annual fuel (8k miles) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Petrol | £3,500–£8,000 | ~15p | ~£1,200 | Best all-rounder |
| Diesel | £4,500–£9,000 | ~13p | ~£1,040 | High mileage only |
| Hybrid | £5,000–£10,000 | ~13p | ~£1,040 | City driving winner |
| Electric | £7,000–£15,000 | ~3.5p* | ~£280* | Not yet for most |
*Electric pence per mile assumes home charging at ~28p/kWh. Public rapid charging costs ~75p/kWh — comparable to petrol. Source: RAC Fuel Watch, Energy Saving Trust 2025.
If you're not sure — buy petrol. Under 12,000 miles a year, mixed driving, first car: petrol. Simple, cheap, widely supported, and the right choice for the vast majority of new drivers.
If you do a lot of city driving and can stretch budget slightly — a petrol hybrid like a Toyota Yaris or Honda Jazz is genuinely excellent and will save you money in the long run.
Diesel: only if you're doing genuine motorway miles. Electric: revisit in a couple of years.
Every listing on StarterMotors shows estimated fuel costs, insurance group, and first-year running costs — so you can compare properly before you commit.
Browse cars →